[Exclusive] Dispute breaks out over overlapping medical helicopter bids

Nov 18, 2026, 11:05 am

print page small font big font

facebook share

x share


A helicopter operator that used a helicopter operating in another region to qualify for bidding on a new project for next year and was subsequently selected as the preferred bidder has been found to have participated in another tender using the same method.


In effect, the company met the eligibility requirements for multiple new tenders using a helicopter that could not be immediately deployed to another project because it was committed to an existing contract. The practice has sparked a dispute between claims that it constitutes the submission of false proposals and arguments that it complies with the criteria set by the contracting authorities.


According to AsiaToday's reporting on Nov. 17, helicopter operator Company A was selected as the first-ranked successful bidder in an Oct. 15 tender issued by the Korea National Oil Corporation (KNOC) for the "2027 Donghae Gas Field Helicopter Operation Services Project," after submitting a bid of 1.471 billion won, equivalent to 82.03% of the estimated contract price. The project involves transporting maintenance personnel and related materials to manage facilities at the Donghae Gas Field's offshore platform. To qualify for the tender, bidders must own at least two helicopters that are no more than 30 years old as of the date of the tender announcement.


According to the Aviation Technical Information System and other sources, Company A currently owns seven helicopters, including two dedicated emergency medical helicopters (doctor helicopters, EC155 B1) deployed and operating in Jeju and five S-76 helicopters. Of these, only the two doctor helicopters in Jeju and one S-76 are no more than 30 years old. In its bid for the Donghae Gas Field project, Company A proposed deploying one S-76 helicopter that meets the age requirement and one of the two doctor helicopters in Jeju.


Company A had previously participated in a tender issued by the National Medical Center (NMC) on Sept. 8 for the "2027 Doctor Helicopter Operation Project for the Jeonnam Region of Jeonnam-Gwangju Special Metropolitan City" and was selected as the preferred bidder. Controversy over the fairness of the tender arose after it emerged that the primary helicopter proposed by Company A for the project was currently operating in Jeju under a contract as a backup helicopter.


At the time, Company A proposed reassigning the backup helicopter, one of the two doctor helicopters in Jeju, as the primary helicopter for Jeonnam by the project's commencement date and purchasing a new helicopter to serve as a backup for both Jeonnam and Jeju.


"Company A used a helicopter from another region to qualify for bidding not only on the Jeonnam project but also on the Donghae Gas Field project," an official from rival Company B said. "It uses a single helicopter in multiple bid proposals and purchases another helicopter to meet the requirements once it secures the contracts. This practice misrepresents its very eligibility to participate in the tenders, and all such proposals constitute false proposals."


"Helicopters are expensive equipment, and numerous external factors could prevent their timely delivery. Yet the relevant authorities are selecting operators based solely on uncertain promises while disregarding the risk of disruptions to emergency medical services," the official continued. "Based on the reference date for determining bidding eligibility, Company A should be deemed not to have met the helicopter ownership requirements, which clearly constitutes grounds for invalidating its bids. Its designation as the preferred bidder should be revoked, and negotiations should be declared unsuccessful."


In response, a Company A official said, "Four years ago, we asked the contracting authority to restrict the use of backup helicopters from other regions as primary helicopters, but our request was rejected. Instead, we received a response indicating that such reassignment could be considered as long as it did not leave a gap in backup helicopter coverage. Our latest proposal was based on that response."


"We submitted proposals using the same method for projects in Jeonbuk and Cheonan this year but were not selected," the official added. "As the outcome can vary depending on the overall content of a proposal, it is difficult to conclude that the reassignment method itself is unfair."


Regarding the Donghae Gas Field project, the official explained, "When we submitted our bid for the Donghae Gas Field project, the contract for the Jeonnam project had not yet been finalized. After reviewing the eligibility requirements for the Donghae Gas Field tender, we determined that we were eligible to participate. In anticipation of undertaking both projects, we took steps to secure a helicopter with the aim of deploying it before operations commenced."


In light of the complaints raised and concerns over the implementation of the projects, Company A has drawn up a revised proposal under which a doctor helicopter would not be deployed for the Donghae Gas Field helicopter operation services project and has asked KNOC to review it.


Meanwhile, KNOC said, "It is difficult to provide a detailed response as the matter is ongoing and the companies concerned have conflicting positions."


                                                                                                            Park Jun-sang

#Medical helicopter #Bid #Aviation 
Copyright by Asiatoday