MIT economist warns of Chinese AI, auto onslaught on U.S., Europe

Nov 17, 2026, 01:52 pm

print page small font big font

facebook share

x share

A robot delivers a cup of ice cream at the media center for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen, Guangdong Province, China, on Nov. 16. Applications of technologies from emerging industries, including artificial intelligence (AI) and robotics, were showcased to the media at the center. /Xinhua-Yonhap News Agency

[Article summary]

1. U.S. economist David Autor warned that the new China shock poses risks to innovation-driven strategic industries such as AI and automobiles, as well as the defense of allies.

2. Research published by Autor and his colleagues found that rising Chinese imports eliminated more than 1.5 million U.S. manufacturing jobs between 1990 and 2007.

3. Jörg Wuttke, former president of the European Union Chamber of Commerce in China, said China's industrial policies have produced both formidable manufacturing capabilities and overcapacity and low profitability.

4. A China expert said Chinese private enterprises account for 60% of the country's gross domestic product (GDP) and 80% of urban employment and are expanding overseas.


A new "China shock 2.0" has hit the United States and Europe as industrial competition with China shifts from textiles, toys, clothing and footwear to key strategic industries such as artificial intelligence (AI) and automobiles, Bloomberg reported on Nov. 16 (local time).


David Autor, an economics professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), said the current competition over advanced industries where innovation takes place presents a greater challenge than the previous shock from Chinese imports. As Chinese companies expand overseas on the strength of their manufacturing base, problems involving overcapacity and geopolitical risks are also emerging.


MIT economist Autor warns China shock 2.0 threatens U.S., European advanced industries and defense of allies


In a study published in 2013 with David Dorn and Gordon Hanson, Autor found that a surge in Chinese imports between 1990 and 2007 had eliminated more than 1.5 million U.S. manufacturing jobs. Some regions experienced sharp increases in unemployment and applications for disability benefits, while subsequent studies also identified political polarization and a decline in the likelihood of young men getting married.


Autor said the United States had suffered losses in the textile, toy, clothing and footwear industries at the time, describing them as unfortunate for workers who lost their jobs but not as strategic losses. However, he pointed out that the current competition centers on advanced strategic industries that drive innovation. Citing the importance of Apple and Boeing, he expressed concern that losing all U.S. automakers would deal a blow to innovation.


Autor said the gap between civilian and military technologies has narrowed more than ever before, citing the example of hobby drones being converted into military weapons. He warned that the United States could face serious risks if it was not prepared to defend itself and its allies. "We are in fierce competition for the 21st century, and we are rapidly falling behind on far too many fronts," he said.


Chinese elementary school students take a coding test at Beijing New Talent Academy (BNTA) in Beijing on June 26. /Reuters-Yonhap News Agency

Autor faults U.S. for failing to use safeguards against Chinese imports, says Trump tariffs helped China

Regarding responses to the new industrial competition, Autor pointed out that the United States had failed to use safeguards that could have slowed the surge in Chinese imports in the past. He said his research at the time had not influenced policy debates as much as he had hoped, emphasizing the need to help affected workers adapt and strategically manage the pace of industrial change.

Autor said China was effective at implementing long-term industrial strategies, while the United States and Europe struggled to sustain effective policies. He said the Joe Biden administration's support for semiconductors and electric vehicles had been designed with a long-term perspective but was short-lived. He described the Donald Trump administration's tariffs and immigration restrictions as shortsighted policies and expressed hope that they, too, would be short-lived.

He said Europe was facing a more severe China shock than the United States had experienced in the past because more of its key industries were being affected. He also presented a hypothetical scenario in which a 40% contraction in Germany's automobile industry would constitute a major shock, and the damage would be far greater if the country were to lose its entire machine tool industry as well.

Autor likened Trump's tariffs to a "blunderbuss" aimed primarily at the United States and its allies, criticizing them for helping China instead. He argued that Chinese President Xi Jinping would regard Trump as a "great gift." Autor also said immigration restrictions were undermining America's strength in attracting the world's best talent, describing the country as "burning away" the foundations of its future growth.

Autor proposed encouraging Chinese companies to establish joint ventures in the United States, noting that China itself had learned a great deal through joint ventures with U.S. companies. However, he opposed a Chinese company's factory producing key application processor (AP) chips in partnership with TSMC, the world's largest semiconductor foundry. He identified solar cells, batteries and automobiles as potential areas of cooperation, saying that although automobiles present challenges because they are "computers on wheels," there is much to learn from Chinese production methods.

Autor said that during his first visit to China in more than a decade this summer, he was surprised by the country's development, safety, low pollution levels, cities made quieter by electric vehicles and orderly appearance. He also pointed to political repression, citing an example in which locals asked him to share a podcast link via AirDrop to their personal phones rather than by email. While criticizing China's human rights record and hypocrisy on international issues, he said there were admirable aspects of its long-term policymaking. He expressed concern about America's long-term direction in contrast to the potential ascendancy of the Chinese model, adding that a proposal for large-scale overseas investment such as the Marshall Plan would be dismissed in Washington today.

Chinese President Xi Jinping holds bilateral talks with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen, China, on Nov. 17 (local time). /EPA-Yonhap News Agency

Former EU Chamber president Wuttke says Chinese automakers rival European leaders


The process through which Chinese manufacturing acquired its formidable competitiveness is also reflected in the experience of Jörg Wuttke, former president of the European Union Chamber of Commerce in China. He served as the chief representative of German chemical company BASF in China for 27 years and headed the chamber on three separate occasions. He moved to Beijing in 1988 and witnessed in Shanghai in 1993 how development plans for Pudong materialized ahead of schedule.


Wuttke said Europe had underestimated the growth of China's automotive industry. Chinese talent had spent decades learning from foreign companies before launching their own businesses and beginning to compete with global leaders, he explained. In particular, by creating "mobile phones on wheels" that combine batteries with digital technology, Chinese automakers had put European companies in a position where they needed to relearn how to manufacture cars.


Wuttke recalled that Li Rongrong, who headed China's agency overseeing state-owned enterprises, had identified industrial policy as the cause of China's overcapacity. Once the central government selects an industry, financing and subsidies are concentrated in that sector, while local governments compete to nurture companies. Even companies with little prospect of profitability remain in business to preserve employment. "Everyone produces. Nobody makes money," he said.


While this structure can undermine the profitability of individual Chinese companies, it creates formidable competitors for other countries, Wuttke said. This is because China has suppliers competing for contracts, an abundance of engineers and a vast domestic market. He said companies capable of competing in China would be prepared to compete in other markets as well.



From left, Rajeev Chauhan, vice president of BYD India's Electric Passenger Vehicles (EPV) business; Shrirang Joshi, vice president of sales and national sales head; and Luo Shuwei, head of marketing for BYD's Asia-Pacific auto sales division, pose at the launch event for the Denza Z9 GT in Mumbai, India, on Nov. 13 (local time). /Reuters-Yonhap News Agency

Wuttke says China's growth has passed its peak


Despite China's manufacturing competitiveness, Wuttke pointed out that its growth model was reaching its limits. The boom in property and infrastructure construction was over, he said, and additional investment in roads, railways, housing and factories was generating diminishing returns in terms of growth. He noted that China continued to favor production over consumption even as its population aged rapidly.


Wuttke said that when he left China in August 2024 after spending nearly 40 years there, he had the impression that the country's growth had passed its peak. However, he stressed that this did not mean China was finished. As a manufacturing powerhouse with vast infrastructure, an extensive industrial base and competitive companies, China would remain a country the world would have to contend with for a long time. He said, however, that the strong optimism he had once experienced was gone.


Participants in the 2026 Jiande Marathon run along a course beside the Xin'an River in Jiande, east China's Zhejiang Province, on Nov. 15 (local time). /Xinhua-Yonhap News Agency

Zhejiang chamber secretary general Yan Cui says Chinese private firms account for 60% of GDP

The overseas expansion of Chinese companies is also reflected in the experience of Yan Cui, secretary general of the Zhejiang Private Economy International Cooperation Chamber of Commerce. He worked at a foreign bank in Beijing when China joined the World Trade Organization (WTO) in late 2001. He explained that foreign banks' client bases subsequently expanded from multinational companies investing in China to Chinese companies expanding overseas, while state-owned enterprises also evolved from subcontractors into main contractors for major projects.

Yan said foreign banks had provided guarantees ranging from millions of dollars (billions of won) to hundreds of millions of dollars (hundreds of billions of won) for Chinese government projects overseas. During the 2008 Russia-Georgia war, Chinese state-owned enterprise China Metallurgical Group Corporation (MCC) suspended construction of a hotel in Tbilisi, the Georgian capital, but its performance guarantee remained in place. The parties agreed to recognize the war as force majeure and temporarily suspend construction and contractual obligations. Yan cited the case as an example of the importance of risk management in overseas projects.

Yan, who took on the task of supporting Zhejiang companies' overseas expansion in 2023, said Chinese private enterprises account for approximately 50% of tax revenue, 60% of GDP and 80% of urban employment. Zhejiang entrepreneurs have expanded overseas guided by the "Four Thousand Spirit," embracing long journeys and hardships. Private companies are also participating in "small but beautiful" projects under the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), encompassing the maritime and overland Silk Roads.

Zhejiang Tenchen Controls acquired Britain's Acro Holdings in 2018. Zhejiang Yinlun Machinery acquired Sweden's Setrab in 2019 and supplied components to luxury automotive brands such as Porsche, Land Rover and Jaguar, Yan explained. Proya Cosmetics established a research and development (R&D) center in France in 2024. Holley Group operates six overseas industrial parks, including those in Thailand and Mexico. Chinese companies are also increasingly relocating industrial supply chains overseas, Yan said.

Yan pointed out that geopolitical risks associated with overseas investment were growing. Policies concerning Chinese investment changed following a leadership transition in Hungary this year, while the British government nationalized a steelworks owned by a Chinese company. These developments have made many Chinese companies more cautious about expanding overseas, he explained. He added that Chinese local governments also prefer private companies to invest domestically rather than overseas because of fiscal and employment pressures.

                                                                                                               Ha Man-joo

#China #AI #Automobile #EU #Trade 
Copyright by Asiatoday