[Exclusive] Hanwha Systems faces union backlash over proposed meal-time deductions

Nov 20, 2026, 09:15 am

print page small font big font

facebook share

x share

Hanwha Group's office building. /Hanwha

Hanwha Systems is reportedly pursuing a plan to automatically deduct employees' breakfast and dinner breaks from their working hours.


Under the proposed system, 30 minutes per meal would be deducted from working hours whenever employees tap their ID cards at the company cafeteria, regardless of how much time they actually spend eating. Management maintains that the measure is intended to ensure accurate tracking of working hours and calculation of overtime pay.


However, the labor union is opposing the plan, arguing that uniform deductions regardless of actual meal times could effectively reduce employees' wages.


AsiaToday learned on Nov. 19 that Hanwha Systems management had proposed a method of calculating working hours based on cafeteria usage records during this year's wage negotiations.


Specifically, 30 minutes would be deducted from an employee's working hours each time they tap their ID card at the cafeteria for breakfast or dinner. Employees who use the cafeteria for both meals would have up to one hour deducted from their working hours per day.


The deducted hours could add up considerably depending on the number of working days. Assuming employees work 22 days a month and use the cafeteria for both breakfast and dinner every working day, 22 hours would be deducted from their working hours each month, or 264 hours annually. Based on an eight-hour workday, this is equivalent to 33 working days a year.


The union takes issue with the fact that a fixed amount of time would be deducted based on ID card taps rather than actual meal times. Hanwha Systems employees can either eat at the company cafeteria or pick up ready-to-eat meals for breakfast and dinner.


This means that the same amount of time could be deducted even if employees simply pick up a meal or return to work after finishing their meals in less than 30 minutes.


Concerns have been raised that this could blur the distinction between actual break time and working time. In particular, the union argues that automatically deducting working hours based on ID card taps could affect the calculation of overtime hours and payment of overtime allowances, even if employees return to work early and put in additional hours.


"One hour a day may not seem like much, but over the course of a year, it could mean 4 million to 5 million won in wages," a union official said, expressing concern.


Management maintains that the proposed measure is not intended to arbitrarily reduce working hours but to accurately track actual working hours and calculate overtime pay under the company's flexible work schedule system.


"The proposed system would exclude meal times from working hours based on employees' ID card taps at the company cafeteria. It is intended to ensure proper accounting of working hours and allowances under our flexible work schedule system," a Hanwha Systems official explained. The official added, however, that the proposal had yet to be finalized and remained under discussion between labor and management.


The controversy arose during Hanwha Systems' wage negotiations this year. Labor and management have held seven rounds of negotiations to date, beginning with the first round of wage talks for 2026 in September. Management has proposed a 130,000 won increase in base pay, while the union is demanding a 6.8% increase in base pay, along with provisions for differentiated payments based on performance.


With labor and management still divided over the size of the wage increase, the emergence of a new dispute over how meal times should be accounted for in working hours is further complicating the negotiations.


Key factors in the negotiations going forward are expected to include how labor and management verify actual meal times, establish criteria for deducting working hours and address the impact of such deductions on overtime pay calculations.


                                                                                                             Kim So-young

#Hanwha Systems #Wage #Labor union #Meal-time 
Copyright by Asiatoday