[Exclusive] Korea Investment & Securities faces churning allegations after client's heavy losses

Nov 20, 2026, 09:15 am

print page small font big font

facebook share

x share


A private banker (PB) at Korea Investment & Securities allegedly advised a client who intended to liquidate all of his financial assets to cover the remaining balance on a home purchase to postpone selling his holdings and continue investing in stocks, suggesting that he could earn up to 100 million won in profits. The banker subsequently recommended switching to other highly volatile foreign stocks with only about two weeks remaining before the payment deadline. The client ultimately incurred realized losses exceeding 100 million won on the two replacement stocks.

Suspicions of excessive trading have also emerged, as the client's cumulative foreign stock sales amounted to 14.2 times his total deposits and trading costs consumed roughly half of his stock trading gains this year. With the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) having conducted inspections of improper sales practices at major Korea Investment & Securities branches from last month through Nov. 18, the company's head office-level transaction oversight and customer protection systems are also coming under scrutiny.

According to transcripts of recorded phone conversations, text messages and transaction statements obtained by AsiaToday on Nov. 19, the client, surnamed Kim, informed his private banker at the company's Bangbae branch on July 30 that he needed to pay the remaining 685 million won on his home purchase by Aug. 31 and intended to sell his stocks by Aug. 25. Kim expressed concerns about further losses, explaining that he would struggle to cover the remaining balance even if he liquidated his stock holdings and took out a loan.

However, on Aug. 11, the banker calculated that Kim would incur 1.5 million won in loan interest if he held onto his stocks for about another 15 days instead of selling them immediately. The banker then advised Kim to postpone selling and continue investing, saying, "If you make a profit, it could be 50 million won or even 100 million won, rather than 1.5 million won." On Aug. 17, the banker proposed that Kim sell his shares in Micron and SanDisk and use the proceeds to purchase shares in POET Technologies and Seagate.

The issue is that the two stocks recommended by the banker were highly volatile, with only about two weeks remaining before the deadline by which the client had stressed he needed to recover his funds. Shares in POET Technologies, an optical communications technology company specializing in artificial intelligence (AI), ranged from a low of $4.87 to a high of $20.81 between January and August this year, a price swing of 327.3%. Over the same period, shares in data storage company Seagate ranged from a low of $276.79 to a high of $1,143.27, representing a price swing of 313.1%. In particular, POET shares fell 20.6% and Seagate shares declined 16.7% between Aug. 17, when the banker recommended the switch, and Aug. 31. Kim incurred realized losses of 154.64 million won when he sold the two stocks on Aug. 31, the deadline for paying the remaining balance on his home purchase.

The substantial costs incurred through repeated stock transactions have also drawn attention. According to records Kim obtained from Korea Investment & Securities, his cumulative deposits between 2023 and 2026 amounted to approximately 2.08 billion won, while his cumulative foreign stock sales over the same period reached 29.64 billion won, roughly 14.2 times his total deposits. Kim's capital gains from foreign stock trading this year totaled 354.07 million won before trading costs, but expenses amounting to 179.38 million won reduced his realized gains to 174.69 million won. Trading costs accounted for 50.7% of his gains before expenses. Kim alleges that the repeated portfolio turnover recommended by the banker may have been intended to generate commission revenue rather than serve the client's interests.

Article 71 of the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act and Article 68 of its Enforcement Decree prohibit recommendations for frequent or excessive trading without due consideration of investors' investment objectives, financial circumstances and other relevant factors. This means that the frequency of recommendations, trading costs and investment objectives must be considered collectively, regardless of whether the client consented to individual transactions.

The controversy comes as the FSS has been warning securities firms against sales practices that prioritize higher trading volumes and commission revenue amid an overheated stock market. In September, the regulator summoned compliance officers from 21 securities firms and raised concerns about practices encouraging excessive margin trading and trading on unsettled funds, as well as passing commissions and other costs on to customers. It also stressed management's oversight responsibilities, citing internal control failures identified at major branches of some securities firms, including unlawful excessive trading and illegal unauthorized and discretionary trading.

In particular, the FSS conducted inspections of major Korea Investment & Securities branches from October through Nov. 18, examining improper sales practices, including excessive trading. However, the regulator said it could not confirm whether this client's case was included in the inspections.

"If trades were executed against the client's wishes, there could be grounds for finding a violation of the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act," an FSS official said. "This is a matter that requires examination of the specific facts, including the investment instruments and amounts involved, the timing of the trades and the nature of the contract."

Meanwhile, a Korea Investment & Securities official said, "An internal investigation into the matter has not yet begun. We will be able to make a determination once the investigation is complete."

                                                                                                          Han Hye-sung
#Korea Investment & Securities #Churning #Investment 
Copyright by Asiatoday